Mac Jones to Trey Lance: QB question marks ahead of new NFL season

Cameron Hogwood

Interviews, Comment & Analysis @ch_skysports

From Mac Jones to Trey Lance to Desmond Ridder – Sky Sports NFL’s Cam Hogwood analyses some of the quarterback question marks around the NFL as teams gear up for the 2023 campaign

Last Updated: 26/05/23 8:18pm

How will New England Patriots quarterback Mac Jones fare in his third year?
How will New England Patriots quarterback Mac Jones fare in his third year?

By this stage most NFL teams will have made and lay down in their quarterback beds as they ramp up preparations for the 2023 season – though not without lingering uncertainty in several cases. 

The situation under center remains an ever-present conundrum in San Francisco as Kyle Shanahan weighs up Brock Purdy, Trey Lance and now even Sam Darnold, while second-year quarterbacks Desmond Ridder and Kenny Pickett seek to prove their worth as long-term options.

Elsewhere in Denver the Broncos are counting on newly-appointed head coach Sean Payton to inspire the best of Russell Wilson after his torrid first year since arriving in a trade from the Seattle Seahawks, and there is a new era underway at Lambeau Field.

As we impatiently await the return of football, here is a look at some of the pressing quarterback questions scattered across the league…

Where is Trey Lance at?

Trey Lance saw his second year cruelly cut short by injury
Trey Lance saw his second year cruelly cut short by injury

When was the last time the quarterback position wasn’t a talking point down in the Bay Area? Shanahan has his fair share of imperfect exes, some of whom offered the picket-fenced 9-5 vanillary stability without ever really generating the oomph of your epiphanic protagonist.

Lance had been pegged as a candidate for the latter, learning behind Jimmy Garoppolo as the rawest of raw rookies in 2021 before seeing his first full year as starter cut short after two games due to injury. Coupled with his truncated college sample, last year’s setback means he will return this season having made just five starts since 2019; that’s not a lot of ball.

Garoppolo would also go down later in 2022, flinging the door open for Mr Irrelevant Brock Purdy to nestle seamlessly into the Shanahan system down the stretch to the extent an injury of his own would derail the Niners’ NFC Championship game against the Philadelphia Eagles. Purdy poise was a thing, so too was Purdy precision as the Iowa State man diced teams from a star-studded dance floor boasting the talent to help veil any rhythm issues.

For all that might be said about the security of Shanahan’s scheme, Lance’s – albeit chiselled – introduction and its flickers of indecisiveness and nervy feet played down any notion of ease. Would the Niners admit a mistake with Lance and devote their immediate future to Purdy? Or would they show patience with a quarterback for whom they gave up three first-round picks to move up and Draft? The latter, it seems. And rightly so, you would say.

But what Lance will it be? What is a Trey Lance? Shanahan drafted who he believed to be his answer to a true quarterback run element in his wide zone system. Let’s see.

What’s happening in New England?

Jones faced competition from Bailey Zappe last season
Jones faced competition from Bailey Zappe last season

How you would love to infiltrate the mind of Bill Belichick in search of his true thoughts on Mac Jones. How you would love to infiltrate the mind of Mac Jones in search of his true thoughts on the New England Patriots offense.

Jones was the most efficient rookie quarterback during the 2021 season as he ranked 11th in EPA+CPOE composite (0.114) in an offense that ranked 11th in dropback EPA, recording a completion percentage of 67.6 with 3,801 passing yards and 22 touchdowns to 13 interceptions. It went as well as could have been anticipated in a unit short of talent – rather than capitalise, the Patriots ripped up what looked a neat blueprint by introducing the defensive mind of Matt Patricia and his simplified hot potato-inciting quick game to replace offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels.

New England would fall to 26th in dropback EPA while Jones, not blameless on his part for the misreads and decision-making and frailties in the face of pressure, ranked 28th in EPA+CPOE composite. An animated Jones voiced his displeasure in not-so-polite terms during December’s loss to the Buffalo Bills, ordering Patricia to “throw the f****** ball”.

Patricia departed earlier this past offseason, with Bill O’Brien coming back across from his post as Alabama offensive coordinator to take the reins. With him likely comes the play-action bread and butter that had been chucked out at the expense of Jones, who, for all the question marks over his arm strength and limitations outside the pocket, is a skilled processor.

JuJu Smith-Schuster and Mike Gesicki were acquired to fill Jakobi Meyers and Jonnu Smith-shaped holes in free agency, but Belichick notably prioritised defense in the Draft following suggestions the Patriots might have been shipping Jones; is Bill content devoting resources to and operating behind a top tier defense while waiting another year to address things at quarterback? Maybe. The Patriots offense will be better, the question of how much better looming as a potentially defining implication as to their plans next offseason.

Is Jordan Love… good?

Jordan Love is primed for his first year as starter in Green Bay
Jordan Love is primed for his first year as starter in Green Bay

The Green Bay Packers turned the page, ultimately by way of a departing Aaron Rodgers, and handed the keys to Jordan Love this offseason. The Jordan Love they had selected with the 26th overall pick in 2020 much to the bemusement of a hacked-off Rodgers. The Jordan Love around whom they have sought to form a younger offensive model in view of the bigger picture. The Jordan Love they have been priming for this exact moment.

Green Bay brass have been waxing lyrical over their new starter under center, citing an upgrade to his instincts and the conviction with which he attacks tight avenues and dunks downfield.

Matt LaFleur’s first real in-game exhibition of what he might have on his hands came in last season’s loss against the Philadelphia Eagles when Love took over from an injured Rodgers to complete six of nine passes for 113 yards and a touchdown. He was settling his feet and allowing plays to materialise, he was making slick decisions in 3×2 spread looks that can be prone to overthinking, he was rolling out and throwing men open off-platform. It was a stark contrast to the Love that had been bombarded by a Steve Spagnuolo all-out blitz after filling in for a Covid-stricken Rodgers at last minute against the Kansas City Chiefs during the 2021 campaign.

With back-end Christian Watson yards-after-catch zoom and a contested catch-savvy deep threat in Romeo Doubs and a smashmouth-capable Aaron Jones-AJ Dillon tandem, Love has the tools to succeed even if he doesn’t dazzle immediately.

Which Russell Wilson will we get?

It was a year to forget for Russell Wilson in Denver - but can Sean Payton bring out the best of the Broncos man?
It was a year to forget for Russell Wilson in Denver – but can Sean Payton bring out the best of the Broncos man?

The Seattle Seahawks lead the ‘who won the Russell Wilson trade?’ poll by a landslide, for now. And strengthened their case further by nabbing a cornerstone cornerback in Devon Witherspoon with the 2023 first-round pick Denver relinquished as part of the deal.

For lovers of Wilson-ball the 2022 season was a gruesome watch as the Broncos quarterback posted a career-low completion percentage while ranking 26th in EPA+CPOE composite and throwing a career-worst 16 touchdowns to 11 interceptions in Nathaniel Hackett’s flatlining offense. Clunky play littered with inaccuracy and ill-guided decision-making was coupled with uncomplimentary opinions from former Seahawks team-mates who, perhaps unjustly, began to criticise his actions during his time in Seattle, all of the above culminating in an outburst of support from Broncos players on social media and in media interviews.

Wilson was missing receivers or gift-wrapping misplaced balls in a faltering quick-game from shotgun, the intention to which was to put the offense in the quarterback’s hands and let him zip short, snappy drive-movers as something of an answer to ‘Let Russ cook’ campaigns. Within that the Broncos failed to strike a necessary balance that would offer any notion of mystery, their rushing attack ranking 28th in EPA and moving away from the play-action that had served Wilson so kindly in years gone by.

A dropback-orientated offense negated from what Wilson has done best throughout his career, and even then his renowned artistry as an outer-pocket off-script sledgehammer looked a shadow of its former self.

Having Javonte Williams – notably coming off a knee injury – and Samaje Perine in the backfield restores the notion of a run game. Having Sean Payton on the sideline introduces a ‘well, look what he did with Drew Brees in play-action’ reassurance. A more Wilson-friendly offense is expected in Denver, and perhaps something not too dissimilar to the Wilson-in-Seattle offense.

Is Desmond Ridder the man?

Atlanta Falcons second-year quarterback Desmond Ridder finds himself armed with a star-sudden offense
Atlanta Falcons second-year quarterback Desmond Ridder finds himself armed with a star-sudden offense

Arthur Smith’s Atlanta Falcons run some funky stuff, packed with misdirection and square-peg-into-round-hole personnel shape-shifting. They make for a fun watch with dynamic playmakers and offensive invention, but how much faith do they have in Desmond Ridder as their long-term starter?

The 2022 third-round pick took over from Marcus Mariota in the latter stages of last season, cobbling together a truncated passing portfolio in his early NFL career as Smith sought to function primarily off his ground game. And why not? The Falcons were pretty good on the ground. Ridder went 73 of 115 passing for 708 yards and two touchdowns in four starters, while also rushing for 64 yards off 16 carries. It was regular heavy-set action with smashmouth run design and the odd sprinkling of some play-action meets Drake London deep shot.

Ridder’s downfield dunking wasn’t spectacular, nor was it asked to be; his tight window dissection wasn’t spectacular, nor was it asked to be. Smith, with due respect to one the winningest quarterbacks in college football history, stripped Ridder of pressure and bit down on the production of Tyler Allgeier to tee up simple crossers and the occasional play action-into-deep shot for London. So to downplay Ridder’s credentials right now would be unfair, because nobody has seen enough.

Spending the eighth overall pick on Texas running back Bijan Robinson jazzes up a standout run game further and points towards ‘sell the run to set up the pass’ support for Ridder, who will have a fit-again Kyle Pitts on hand to work with London.

Is Kenny Pickett also the man?

Will we see a leap from Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kenny Pickett?
Will we see a leap from Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kenny Pickett?

Question marks had their own question marks when it came to a 2022 quarterback Draft class that struggled to enamour, of which Kenny Pickett became the sole first-round pick as he stayed put in the city where he had played college football and where he had likely brushed shoulders with Mike Tomlin on more than one occasion.

By the second half of the Week Four loss to the New York Jets he had taken over as starter for Mitchell Trubisky, awaiting him a gyrating yet stagnant Matt Canada offense and early teething issues amounting to turnover trouble and uneasy decision-making. Pickett grew in unison with Tomlin’s ‘we shall not own a losing record’ inevitability over the second half of the season, squeezing himself into the top 10 in quarterback EPA/play after the Week Nine bye as Pittsburgh won seven of their final nine games while ranking fourth in EPA, in which they had ranked 28th across the first nine games.

The Canada factor will be defining in Pickett’s sophomore development as the offensive coordinator fights to swat away doubts over his long-term credentials, social media consensus among Steelers fans seemingly being that he was fortunate to retain his post. His faults had entailed mismatched blocking assignments, self-imposed numerical disadvantages at the line of scrimmage, a continued commitment to cramming in pre-snap motion that was having little effect on defensive alignment and a shortage of downfield aggression. But by the close of the season Pittsburgh began to offer the traits of a well-drilled split zone offense with linebacker-displacing jet sweep motions, Derek Watt and Connor Heyward-led wham blocking and a confident Najee Harris punching gaps cleared by interior double-teams or bang-and-bouncing to secondary lanes. Finally there was a run to sell that would help prop up a rookie Pickett.

As for Pickett himself, reminders of the out-of-structure prowess and precision evident in college were there after some early season struggles. Skedaddling from the pocket and zinging passes on the move is customary to the modern NFL and the modern quarterback job specification, but year two will involve finding out how efficient he can be as a drop-back-in-structure sucker for convention who can make things happen from the pocket.

In Calvin Austin III he gets a legitimate downfield flyer with which to complement George Pickens after the 2022 draft pick missed his rookie year through injury, while the arrival of tight end behemoth Darnell Washington to partner Pat Freiermuth along with former Philadelphia Eagles guard Isaac Seumalo and rookie tackle Broderick Jones reinforces a meaty blockade in aid of supporting both him and Harris. The Steelers are an interesting one this coming September.

Shop the latest NFL jerseys!
Snap up your team’s jersey and rep it throughout the season. There are snack helmets, wall signs, bottle openers and 500-piece jigsaws to grab too.
Sign up and save 10% off your first purchase. Go to to find out how.

Stay across Sky Sports NFL’s digital and social channels for the latest news and analysis as we build up to the new season; you can also catch Neil Reynolds and Jeff Reinebold on Inside the Huddle as they discuss the big storylines around the league.

Source : Sky Sports