Harvard University announced Thursday it’s releasing a high-quality dataset of nearly one million public-domain books that could be used by anyone to train large language models and other AI tools. The dataset was created by Harvard’s newly formed Institutional Data Initiative with funding from both Microsoft and OpenAI. It contains books scanned as part of the Google Books project that are no longer protected by copyright.
Around five times the size of the notorious Books3 dataset that was used to train AI models like Meta’s Llama, the Institutional Data Initiative’s database spans genres, decades, and languages, with classics from Shakespeare, Charles Dickens, and Dante included alongside obscure Czech math textbooks and Welsh pocket dictionaries. Greg Leppert, executive director of the Institutional Data Initiative, says the project is an attempt to “level the playing field” by giving the general public, including small players in the AI industry and individual researchers, access to the sort of highly-refined and curated content repositories that normally only established tech giants have the resources to assemble. “It’s gone through rigorous review,” he says.
Leppert believes the new public domain database could be used in conjunction with other licensed materials to build artificial intelligence models. “I think about it a bit like the way that Linux has become a foundational operating system for so much of the world,” he says, noting that companies would still need to use additional training data to differentiate their models from those of their competitors.
Burton Davis, Microsoft’s vice president and deputy general counsel for intellectual property, emphasized that the company’s support for the project was in line with its broader beliefs about the value of creating “pools of accessible data” for AI startups to use that are “managed in the public’s interest.” In other words, Microsoft isn’t necessarily planning to swap out all of the AI training data it has used in its own models with public domain alternatives like the books in the new Harvard database. “We use publicly available data for the purposes of training our models,” Davis says.
As dozens of lawsuits filed over the use of copyrighted data for training AI wind their way through the courts, the future of how artificial intelligence tools are built hangs in the balance. If AI companies win their cases, they’ll be able to keep scraping the internet without needing to enter into licensing agreements with copyright holders. But if they lose, AI companies could be forced to overhaul how their models get made. A wave of projects like the Harvard database are plowing forward under the assumption that—no matter what happens—there will be an appetite for public domain datasets.
In addition to the trove of books, the Institutional Data Initiative is also working with the Boston Public Library to scan millions of articles from different newspapers now in the public domain, and it says it’s open to forming similar collaborations down the line. The exact way the books dataset will be released is not settled. The Institutional Data Initiative has asked Google to work together on public distribution, but the search giant hasn’t publicly agreed to host it yet, though Harvard says it’s optimistic it will. (Google did not respond to WIRED’s requests for comment.)
However IDI’s dataset is released, it will be joining a host of similar projects, startups, and initiatives that promise to give companies access to substantial and high-quality AI training materials without the risk of running into copyright issues. Firms like Calliope Networks and ProRata have emerged to issue licenses and design compensation schemes designed to get creators and rightholders paid for providing AI training data.
There are also other new public-domain projects. Last spring, the French AI startup Pleis rolled out its own public-domain dataset, Common Corpus, which contains an estimated 3 to 4 million books and periodical collections, according to project coordinator Pierre-Carl Langlais. Backed by the French Ministry of Culture, the Common Corpus has been downloaded over 60,000 times this month alone on the open source AI platform Hugging Face. Last week, Pleis announced that it is releasing its first set of large language models trained on this dataset, which Langlais told WIRED constitute the first models “ever trained exclusively on open data and compliant with the [EU] AI Act.”
Efforts are underway to create similar mage datasets as well. AI startup Spawning released its own this summer called Source.Plus, which contains public-domain images from Wikimedia Commons as well as a variety of museums and archives. Several significant cultural institutions have long made their own archives accessible to the public as standalone projects, like the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Ed Newton-Rex, a former executive at Stability AI who now runs a nonprofit that certifies ethically-trained AI tools, says the rise of these datasets shows that there’s no need to steal copyrighted materials to build high-performing and quality AI models. OpenAI previously told lawmakers in the United Kingdom that it would be “impossible” to create products like ChatGPT without using copyrighted works. “Large public domain datasets like these further demolish the ‘necessity defense’ some AI companies use to justify scraping copyrighted work to train their models,” Newton-Rex says.
But he still has reservations about whether the IDI and projects like it will actually change the training status quo. “These datasets will only have a positive impact if they’re used, probably in conjunction with licensing other data, to replace scraped copyrighted work. If they’re just added to the mix, one part of a dataset that also includes the unlicensed life’s work of the world’s creators, they’ll overwhelmingly benefit AI companies,” he says.
Source : Wired
